Accessible Tub vs. Shower: Which One Is Right for You?

When designing an accessible bathroom, you might find yourself choosing between the bathtub or shower. Whether you’re planning your own bathroom renovation for your forever home or making accommodations for an elderly loved one, you can count on The Bathroom Store to help you make an informed decision. In this article, we discuss the benefits you can get when you choose either an accessible bathtub or shower, as well as explore the different options available for each that will ensure maximum comfort, safety, and functionality.

Accessible Tub Options

A world of possibilities awaits when you choose the bathtub for your accessible remodeling. There are two popular options: walk-in tubs and slide-in tubs.

Walk-in tubs have a built-in, watertight door, allowing easier entry and exit without stepping over a high threshold. With comfortable built-in seating and anti-slip floors, these tubs offer a safer bathing experience, especially for those with mobility challenges. Many models also come with hydrotherapy jets, which can help soothe sore muscles, ease pain from arthritis, and improve circulation. These treatments can relieve symptoms of restless leg syndrome, Parkinson’s disease, neuropathy, and gout in the privacy of your own home. However, a potential drawback is the time it takes to fill and drain the tub, as you need to be inside the tub with the door closed during this process.
Slide-in tubs are designed for individuals who use wheelchairs or have difficulty lifting their legs over traditional tub edges. They feature a wide, flat entry and a space for the bather to transfer from a wheelchair or other assistive device directly onto the tub seat. Once securely seated, the individual can slide their legs into the tub. While it’s easy to use for wheelchair users, this accessible tub may require more bathroom space than a walk-in tub and can be more expensive.

Tub Replacement Considerations

If you are considering a tub replacement, there are a few factors to keep in mind. For one, accessible tubs typically require more space than traditional tubs, so you’ll need to assess if your bathroom can accommodate the size of the new tub. It is also important to take note of your bathroom’s plumbing system. Depending on your chosen model, you may need to make plumbing adjustments, such as installing new fixtures or rerouting pipes. Since accessible tubs can be more expensive than standard tubs, it’s also a good idea to plan your budget ahead of time.

Accessible Shower Options

On the other hand, if you prefer showers over tubs, the two most popular options to consider are roll-in showers and barrier-free showers.

Roll-in showers feature a level, barrier-free entry that allows wheelchair users to enter without stepping over a threshold. They typically come with a built-in or fold-down seat and strategically placed grab bars for added safety and convenience. This shower option can easily accommodate wheelchair users, but water containment can be challenging, as the open entry may lead to water splashing onto the bathroom floor.
Barrier-free showers are similar to roll-in showers in that they have a level, curbless entry. However, this shower option often has a collapsible water retainer or a sloped floor to help keep water inside the shower area. Like roll-in showers, barrier-free showers offer easy access for those with mobility challenges. The added water containment features can also help keep your bathroom floor dry and safe.

Shower Seat Options

When planning a shower installation to improve accessibility, there are a few shower seat options to consider for added comfort and safety. Built-in seats, for instance, are sturdy additions to an accessible shower. Meanwhile, fold-down seats can be folded up when not in use, providing more space within the shower. However, if you prefer a flexible solution, there are also portable shower seats that can be easily moved and adjusted.

Additional Bathroom Accessibility Features

To create a fully accessible bathroom, there are many additional features you may want to invest in. We list a few examples to consider:

Grab bars. For additional support and safety in your bathroom, install grab bars near the toilet, tub, and shower. Be sure to choose from various types and materials to match your bathroom’s design.
Sink installations. For your sink installation, take note of the height and clearance beneath the sink to accommodate a wheelchair user. Additionally, select faucets with easy-to-use handles or lever designs for increased accessibility.
Toilet modifications. To further enhance bathroom safety and comfort, you may want to install a raised toilet seat or add support rails near the toilet.
Bath tape. Bath tape, also known as bath strips, shower and tub treads, or anti-slip discs, adds friction to slippery surfaces such as your tub, shower, or bathroom floor.
Durable flooring. When selecting flooring materials, opt for slip-resistant options for your tile installation, such as textured tile or slip-resistant vinyl. Don’t forget to consider the maintenance requirements of each material to find a durable and practical choice.
Lighting fixtures. The ideal lighting fixtures should ensure a safe and user-friendly bathroom environment. Install overhead lights, task lighting near mirrors, and night lights to provide sufficient illumination and visibility for all your needs, day and night.

We Have Your Safety in Mind

Choosing the perfect tub or shower for your accessible bathroom is a personal decision that depends on your unique needs and preferences. Regardless of your choice, always prioritize safety and comfort and work with a professional bathroom contractor. An expert will help assess your needs and preferences and guide you through the process, from selecting a suitable tub or shower to making the necessary modifications.

For top-notch bathroom remodeling services, look no further than The Bathroom Store in Bismarck, ND. Our team of bathroom remodelers offers reliable solutions and state-of-the-art materials to ensure your new bathroom remains functional and stylish for years to come. When you work with us, you can rest easy knowing that your home is in safe hands. For a free consultation, call us today at (701) 223-1008. You can also fill out our contact form on our website to request an estimate.